{"id":75958,"date":"2026-11-22T19:12:07","date_gmt":"2026-11-22T19:12:07","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/articles\/between-obedience-and-the-right-to-life-sina-yousefi\/"},"modified":"2026-11-22T19:12:53","modified_gmt":"2026-11-22T19:12:53","slug":"between-obedience-and-the-right-to-life-sina-yousefi","status":"publish","type":"articles","link":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/en\/articles\/between-obedience-and-the-right-to-life-sina-yousefi\/","title":{"rendered":"Between Obedience and the Right to Life \/ Sina Yousefi"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>War, regardless of the aims and justifications that governments put forward to start or continue it, is always accompanied by heavy human costs. Among those who pay these costs, conscript soldiers occupy a particular position, because many of them enter the military structure without any real freedom of choice and solely in fulfilment of the legal obligation of compulsory service, and may find themselves in a situation where their life and health depend on commanders\u2019 decisions and orders. They typically have little say in determining when and where they are deployed to operational areas, the type of mission, and the level of risk they face, and refusing to carry out a mission can also bring disciplinary and criminal consequences.<\/p>\n<p>Iran\u2019s recent war with Israel and the United States once again laid bare the human and legal dimensions of this situation. Despite a relative halt to large-scale hostilities, no lasting agreement to end the war has yet been reached, and the region\u2019s military and political developments show that the risk of renewed attacks and a fresh escalation of fighting remains serious. Recent reports on military developments in the region and the continuation of disputes over an agreement to end the war also point to the fragility of the current situation. In such circumstances, attention to the situation of conscript soldiers and the extent of legal protection afforded to them becomes doubly important.<\/p>\n<p>A soldier who is exposed to a military mission does not lose his fundamental rights merely by virtue of membership in the armed forces, and his right to life and physical integrity cannot be entirely disregarded in the face of the requirements of the military chain of command. From this perspective, it must be asked: what are the limits of a soldier\u2019s obligation to obey a commander\u2019s order, and is he required to carry out even orders that, without operational necessity or military justification, place his life in serious and avoidable danger? Likewise, if a soldier refuses to carry out such an order in order to protect his life, should the legal system punish him as insubordinate, or should it also examine the conditions under which the order was issued, its nature, and the risk arising from its execution? Answering these questions requires examining the relationship between the requirements of military service, the right to life, the limits of commanders\u2019 responsibility, and the legal guarantees for conscript soldiers.<\/p>\n<p>Obedience to commanders\u2019 orders is one of the essential requirements of the armed forces\u2019 structure and a prerequisite for maintaining military order and cohesion, but this requirement cannot mean unconditional obedience to any command, regardless of its nature, legality, and consequences. The commander\u2013soldier relationship, even in wartime, does not fall outside the framework of law, and the military hierarchy cannot become a tool for depriving soldiers of their fundamental rights. A conscript soldier, like any other citizen, enjoys the right to life and physical integrity, and his presence within the military structure does not mean relinquishing these rights.<\/p>\n<p>From this perspective, a distinction must be drawn between orders whose execution entails accepting the ordinary and unavoidable risks of military operations and orders that, without operational necessity and military justification, place a soldier in serious and preventable danger. For example, deploying soldiers to a high-risk operational position is not necessarily unlawful merely because there is a possibility of casualties, since the nature of military operations involves risk. However, if a mission is designed and carried out without an appropriate risk assessment, without providing necessary protective facilities and equipment, or with disregard for accessible measures to reduce casualties, its legitimacy can be examined in light of command responsibility and legal requirements. Therefore, the dangerousness of a mission alone is not the criterion for determining the unlawfulness of an order; rather, military necessity, the intended objective, proportionality between the importance of the mission and the risk imposed on soldiers, and the possibility of adopting alternative or protective measures must be assessed.<\/p>\n<p>These considerations also have a direct connection to fundamental principles of international law. Article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights recognizes the right to life, and the UN Human Rights Committee, in General Comment No. 36, has emphasized that protection of this right continues even in situations of armed conflict. Likewise, the rules of international humanitarian law oblige parties to a conflict to take the necessary precautions, in planning and conducting military operations, to reduce casualties and human harm. Although these rules are primarily concerned with protecting victims of conflict and limiting the effects of military operations, the principles of necessity and precaution are also important in analysing commanders\u2019 responsibility and how they treat the lives of forces under their command.<\/p>\n<p>On the other hand, it must not be forgotten that conscript soldiers, due to their employment and military position, typically do not have bargaining power or the ability to freely oppose commanders\u2019 decisions, and this power imbalance makes the need to provide effective legal protections all the more urgent. In such circumstances, a soldier who faces an order whose execution endangers his life in an unnecessary and avoidable way should be able to raise an objection and request a review of the mission without fear of arbitrary punishment. Ultimately, the obligation of military obedience cannot negate commanders\u2019 responsibility for their decisions, and the state cannot, by invoking a wartime situation, treat any imposed and unjustified risk-taking as an unavoidable part of military service.<\/p>\n<p>In Iranian law, one of the most significant obstacles facing conscript soldiers who refuse to carry out dangerous orders is the criminal and disciplinary regulations relating to disobedience of commanders\u2019 orders. The Law on Punishment of Crimes of the Armed Forces also subjects conscript personnel, during their service, to military criminal provisions and has provided for severe punishments for defying commanders\u2019 orders, especially in wartime. For example, under Article 37 of this law, refusing to carry out an order to move toward the enemy, depending on the circumstances and consequences, can entail punishments up to the level of \u201cmoharebeh (waging war against God)\u201d or long-term imprisonment. Article 38 also provides imprisonment for disobeying other commanders\u2019 orders in cases where the conduct is not considered merely a disciplinary violation. Alongside these provisions, certain behaviours related to refusing to perform combat duties or abandoning a mission may also be prosecuted under other criminal headings. Within such a framework, a conscript soldier who disobeys an order may face an accusation of insubordination without, at the outset, proper attention being paid to the reasons and circumstances that compelled him to make that decision.<\/p>\n<p>The fundamental problem is that the existing regulations do not draw a clear distinction between an arbitrary refusal to carry out a lawful and militarily necessary order and a refusal to carry out an order that, without operational necessity, places a soldier\u2019s life in serious and avoidable danger, nor have they provided clear protection for the soldier in the latter situation. As a result, soldiers may find themselves caught between two difficult situations: on the one hand, carrying out an order that may cost them their life or health, and on the other, refusing it and facing criminal and disciplinary punishments. This situation, especially in wartime and in an environment where the possibility of effectively objecting to commanders\u2019 decisions is limited, can create the conditions for abuse of military authority and the disregard of soldiers\u2019 rights. For this reason, in adjudicating an accusation of insubordination, it should not be sufficient merely to note non-execution of the order; rather, the legality of the command, the necessity of issuing it, the level of foreseeable risk, the possibility of adopting protective measures, and the soldier\u2019s reasons for refusal must also be examined independently. Otherwise, regulations enacted to preserve military order may, in practice, become a tool to force soldiers to accept unnecessary risks and to prevent them from defending their right to life and their own health.<\/p>\n<p>Responsibility for safeguarding soldiers\u2019 lives in wartime does not rest solely with the soldiers themselves; military commanders and the responsible structures also bear responsibility for decisions, orders, and the way military operations are organized. Military command does not mean possessing unlimited authority to deploy forces under one\u2019s command, and every commander is obliged, before issuing an order, to assess the necessity of the mission, the level of foreseeable risks, and the resources required to protect the forces.<\/p>\n<p>Deploying soldiers to operational areas without appropriate protective equipment, forcing them into positions whose risks can be reduced by reasonable measures, or using conscript forces for missions that lack necessity and military justification can raise the responsibility of commanders and decision-making officials. In this regard, international humanitarian law, by emphasizing the principles of military necessity, proportionality, and precaution, imposes limitations on how military operations are designed and conducted. Although a significant part of these rules has been developed with the aim of protecting civilians and other protected persons in armed conflicts, compliance with requirements relating to precaution and the reduction of preventable harm is also important in assessing commanders\u2019 conduct.<\/p>\n<p>Moreover, the right to life, recognized in international human rights law, is not fully suspended even in wartime, and states remain responsible for the actions of the armed forces and for decisions that unnecessarily place people\u2019s lives at risk. In such circumstances, merely invoking the exigencies of war or the necessity of carrying out a mission cannot immunize every command decision from legal oversight and assessment. Another important issue is the possibility of holding commanders accountable who, by disregarding obvious and preventable risks, endanger the lives of soldiers under their command. Such accountability requires independent mechanisms to investigate incidents, record and document operational orders, address soldiers\u2019 complaints, and protect those who report existing dangers or the unlawfulness of an order. In the absence of such mechanisms, a conscript soldier effectively remains defenceless in the face of command authority, and the possibility of pursuing responsibility for those who exposed him to unnecessary danger becomes severely limited.<\/p>\n<p>Ultimately, it must be accepted that placing an individual in the position of a conscript soldier and legally obliging him to perform military service does not mean handing over his right to life and physical integrity to commanders or waiving his fundamental human rights. The state cannot, on the one hand, make military service compulsory and, on the other, absolve itself of any accountability for dangers that confront soldiers as a result of irresponsible decisions and orders lacking necessity. Conscript soldiers have the right to be assured of the legality of issued orders, to object to missions that expose their lives to unnecessary risks, and, where there is justified refusal to carry out such orders, to enjoy legal protection. Realizing this right requires reforming criminal and disciplinary regulations, providing independent mechanisms to review contested orders, and guaranteeing the absence of arbitrary prosecution of soldiers who, to protect their lives, refuse to carry out unlawful or unjustifiably issued commands. It should also be possible to file complaints against commanders who, with disregard for safety requirements and humanitarian considerations, expose forces under their command to avoidable risks.<\/p>\n<p>War must not become a situation in which commanders\u2019 responsibility for the lives of forces under their command is ignored and soldiers, due to their weaker position within the military structure, are compelled to accept any level of risk; especially in a country where military service remains compulsory, the state bears an additional responsibility for the lives of those who are called up without free choice. Defending the country and public security cannot require disregarding the right to life of citizens who wear a military uniform. No military objective or governmental expediency can justify the unregulated endangerment of human lives, and no soldier should be forced, to preserve his life, to choose between death on the battlefield and punishment for disobeying an unnecessary order.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Conscript soldiers\u2019 right to refuse dangerous orders in war<\/p>\n","protected":false},"featured_media":75881,"template":"","meta":{"_acf_changed":false,"inline_featured_image":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[5460,55185],"tags":[57693,50767,57687,57691,57666,57671,57667,57692,50372,50210,56305],"class_list":["post-75958","articles","type-articles","status-publish","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-articles","category---subcategories","tag-commanders-responsibility","tag-compulsory-military-service","tag-conscripts-2","tag-military-obedience","tag-peace-line-2","tag-peace-line-monthly-3","tag-peace-mark-187","tag-refusal-to-obey-an-order","tag-right-to-life","tag-sina-yousefi","tag-the-war-between-iran-and-israel"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/articles\/75958","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/articles"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/articles"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/articles\/75958\/revisions"}],"acf:post":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/author\/39508"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/75881"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=75958"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=75958"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.peace-mark.org\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=75958"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}